A further ten seconds later, 'Flaps 2' is selected. Re: Pilots that make mistakes -- Where are they today? The pilot was told, word-of-mouth, to do so. Flight deck crew. Everyone airminded in France knows that Michel Asseline, who was an Air France chief pilot instructor at the beginning of the Airbus A-320 era and PIC in the A-320 that crashed at Mulhouse-Habsheim airfield in June 1988, resumed his career some years after the accident as a Boeing-737 pilot in Australia. The low-speed flyover, with landing gear down, was supposed to take place at an altitude of 100 feet (30m); instead, the plane performed the flyover at 30ft (9m), skimmed the treetops of the forest at the end of the runway (which had not been shown on the airport map given to the pilots) and crashed. Although three people died in the crash _ two of them children _ 137 passengers and crew escaped. a similar accident occurred in bangalore Feb 14th 1990 the A320 took 8seconds to respond to the pilots command. It was a demonstration charter flight, Air France Flight 296. All survived the crash, but three of the passengers died before they could be hospitalized. It's kind of hard to prove that pilots and conditions WOULD have messed up if they had truly been in control of all flights all these years. Michel Asseline (Captain) After being sentenced, was temporarily banned from flying in France as part of a court agreement, moved to Australia and flew 737s. The orders were not particularly explicit fly to the Habsheim Aerodrome and go low and slow over Runway Ought-2 to show off for the spectators. 12:44:45 - 'Flaps 3' is selected as the aircraft descends through 500 feet (150m) at an airspeed of 177 knots. This is NOT to say the Airbus' control system has not prevented plenty of crashes. [1] On 26 June 1988, the plane crashed while making a low pass over MulhouseHabsheim Airfield (ICAO airport code LFGB) as part of the Habsheim Air Show. Guilty. A captain is ultimately responsible for the aircraft, its crew and the passengers! [ 1,292 more word ] [1], At the time of the incident, only three of the new aircraft type had been delivered to Air France, and the newest one (in service for two days) had been chosen for the flyover. He did none of this which can be fine given he contacted the tower first. Get a job criticizing nobody blames you for doing that. ), You can read more about this here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296. Its systems would not allow for mistakes. The Airbus A320 couldnt handle it. He continued flying and after two years he became a captain again Everyone airminded in France knows that Michel Asseline, who was an Air France chief pilot instructor at the beginning of the Airbus A-320 era and PIC in the A-320 that crashed at Mulhouse-Habsheim airfield in June 1988, resumed his career some years after the accident as a Boeing-737 pilot in Australia. What is crucial is to understand the threats that can lead to errors, look at how those threats can be mitigated, and have procedures in place that allow errors to be caught and resolved before they become a safety event. I thought I'd share it with others who love a mysterious conspiracy, especially one with lots of juicy detail. The plane crashed because of a design defect; but because it was software and not metal, it was ignored. Captain Michel Asseline, 44, had been an airline pilot with Air France for almost 20 years and had the following endorsements: Caravelle, Boeing 707, 727, and 737, and Airbus A300 and A310. Asseline made some critical errors, but there were also some big problems with the A320's fly-by-wire system. Theres many more lessons to be learned about the practice of medicine from the story of Prisoner Michel Asseline sorry, Captain Michel Asseline. Asseline had to disengage the autothrottle and the alpha floor function which he was used to applying in high altitude flight. Menu. For more information, please see our You must learn and follow the rules otherwise you may DIE or kill someone else and die.This one fact that Michael choose to fly at 100ft that Michael performed as the pilot in charge of this Aircraft is sufficient to place the guilt firmly in his lap. The flight plan originally filed did not include the flyover of the Habsheim Air Show, which was added on the morning of the flight. *Defects come in all shades. Pilots are charged with the safety of their passengers first and foremost. The computer didnt know he meant just to pop up a few hundred feet. But its all about me and you. The A320 had been recently introduced, and Flight 296 was the first passenger flight of the A320. It is BASIC knowledge!!! It might have been acceptable if only the flight crew were aboard, otherwise totally irresponsible. Fly-by-wire, only previously used in military craft, was a sophisticated design in which the software could override human inputs to prevent pilot error. We thank you for your support and hope you'll join the largest aviation community on the web. Some passengers had difficulty unfastening their seatbelts because they were unfamiliar with the mechanism (which differs from the type used in car seatbelts). On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. ALL pilots KNOW, that there is a spool up time on jetengines. I am Captain Michel. Traduzioni in contesto per "had the endorsement" in inglese-italiano da Reverso Context: I hope the Commission will pay very serious attention to them since they have had the endorsement also of the Regional Affairs Committee. Not unless their was prior approval by the proper authorities that made the rules that allowed for him to break it. Why be a sucker? His arrogance, recklessness, lack of skills and knowledge destroyed a plane and killed 2 children and an adult. The others were sentenced to probation. Spectral analysis of the engine sounds indicated that 0.6 seconds later, both engines had reached 91% (by this stage, they were starting to ingest vegetation). Facts: 1) new plane (model/style) = bugs still to be discovered & pilots not familiar w how plane functions (new technology / automation) 2) pilot was not familiar w air field not shown air field and only given a map of it (inaccurate map showing no terrain) right before the flight 3) air France never should have had people on the flight except crew knowing all these factors. ), The Prison of Precision by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph.D. It was the third A320 delivered to Air France, the launch customer. He did the best he could. 12:43:44 - the aircraft begins its descent from 2,000 feet (610m), initially at a rate of 300 feet (91m) per minute with 'Flaps 1'. Captain Asseline was flying to Mont Blanc, period. If you remove management edicts and substitute human judgment, you can eliminate 19 out of 20 errors. Everyone thought it was a no-brainer for the A320 to wow this crowd. It threatened to ruin the reputation of the A320, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales. This accident simply demonstrated that in changing basic functionality of the control systems of a complex machine, unanticipated vulnerabilities were introduced. Some individual in Texas, I read a little excerpt from book written by a man whom I quite dislike,. Three seconds later, the aircraft descends through 40 feet (12m) at an airspeed of 132 knots. It takes a series of things to go wrong. The evacuation from the rear door had been fast and smooth thanks to the instructions from the flight attendants at the rear of the aircraft. Runway to pass over - again wrong. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I don't know how passenger survived. The plan was to overfly Runway Ought-2; the aircraft was configured for a low-altitude overflight. I mostly blame the French courts for adding insult to injury and imposing a prison sentence on a man who may have faults, but definitely is not guilty of manslaughter. My feeling: pilot did as he was told by air France. In the process, the purser and the passenger were thrown out of the fuselage with the slide landing on top of them. Overflight at this altitude made the demonstration to the crowd even more awe-inspiring. . Guilty. Unprofessional. Local emergency services were informed by radio communication. It's about commercial aviation, and I've tried to include all the relevant facts for you to draw conclusions. Overflight at this altitude made the demonstration to the crowd even more awe-inspiring. . And air law states that 500ft is the minimum height for air shows. This was yet another unanticipated vulnerability. The A320 had been recently introduced, and Flight 296 was the first passenger flight of the A320. One was a disabled boy in seat 4F who was unable to move. When he increased throttle to level off at 100ft, the engines did not respond. Passenger cabin shots showing seat arrangements as well as cargo aircraft interior, Cargo Aircraft You are Captain Michel Asseline. Air France was especially impressed with the A320, which was the first fly-by-wire airplane ever to carry passengers. 500 feet is the law it is not simple a suggestion. Some seconds later the aircraft touched the tops of the trees behind the runway and crashed into a forest. They might be paid, or simply represent interest of a much more powerful players - Air France. Christian Roger, a professional pilot, complained energetically about the fact-finding process around the crash. However, while the pilots were trained in metric, this particular plane was in Imperial units. My father was THE senior test pilot for the British Civil Aviation Authority at the time of the crash and knew the French pilot personally. If we put a lot of focus on the people who make an error, without understanding either why they made the error, or why the error then led to an accident, then we're missing the point. I agree the pilot was culpable. Here's a story about me and you. Edit. Man can find signs of manipulation in recorded data, missing data etc. Interruption of the power occurred forward of the tail sectionmost probably in the wheel-well area, which was heavily damaged. It was piloted by a premier captain of Air France, Captain Michel Asseline, with over10,000 air hours, and led the training division of Air France for qualifying pilots on the Airbus 320. Asseline, who had been a senior pilot with Air France for eight years, maintained the pilots were unfairly blamed, and said the plane had failed to respond quickly to attempts to raise it. Captain Asseline, First Officer Mazire, two Air France employees and the sponsor of the event, president of the local flight club, were charged with the crime of involuntary manslaughter, of the group Captain Asseline was the only one who ended up in jail convicted to 10 months in prison, while the rest ended up on probation. I'm not cocky - I'm just good at my job. Both military and civil versions, Blimps / Airships Do you feel that Captain Asseline should have aborted the flyover? 12:45:15 - the aircraft, now at 90 feet (27m), begins a deviation to the right (maximum bank angle: 30) to line up with the grass strip 34R. auto throttle at one of the floor limits) misjudged the situation (the length of the runway, and altitude of the plane), and didn't know the performance of the aircraft sufficiently well (engine spool up times) to safely perform the manoeuvre he was undertaking. Most of the public believes Airbus' controls systems were the root cause of this crash, or at least a major part of it. It would not open, which was fortunate as there was by that time a fire on the left wing. Michel Asseline, a senior pilot with Air France for eight years, was fired Wednesday following a particularly grave failure for which he was held responsible and which made his continued employment with Air France impossible, a company spokesman said. Due to the many demands of redirection and reconfiguration, the craft flew above Runway 34R at 30 feet, not the usual 100 feet which is standard for low-altitude demonstration overflight. The purser, a passenger, and a flight attendant (a guest from another airline) managed to push the door fully open. The translated version of the report can be found on the Aviation Accidents Database and at the Aviation Safety Network. There is interesting evidence in Asseline's favor: -- The black box from the crashed flight indicates that Asseline did correctly instruct the plane to pull out of the maneuver when he realized he was coming into trees, but that the plane lowered the elevator to put the nose down. This is specifically in reference to the fact that the Airbus 320 system would consider the craft landing when it was low to the ground and override the Captain's ability to pull the craft up. I have a hard time believing that the pilot was literally four seconds from the trees when he applied power. He was leader of the French air force's aerobatics team and, later, a Boeing 747 Flight Captain with Air France. I have no doubt the pilot was to blame, and the conspiracy theorists (tampering with a black box?) As usual, I believe the truth is somewhere in the middle. Bullshit. Captain Asseline, who maintained his innocence, would go on to serve ten months of prison and a further ten months of probation.[3]. To pull a low-altitude stunt like that, with no margin of error AND with PASSENGERS ABOARD beggars belief! If you remove management edicts and substitute human judgment, you can eliminate 19 out of 20 errors. Mazires was given a twelve month suspended sentence. This and another point i wish to make the fact that most pilots would have performed a procedure called a go around when approaching an airport that you are unfamiliar with. [2] The flyover had been approved by Air France's Air Operations Directorate and Flight Safety Department, and air traffic control and Basel tower had been informed. *Management often screws around. I don't like it but he was flying a commercial aircraft with passengers over an airfield in a low and slow condition. [1] A training captain since 1979, Asseline was appointed to head the company's A320 training subdivision at the end of 1987. The captain, Michel Asseline, disputed the report and claimed an error in the fly-by-wire computer prevented him from applying thrust and pulling up. On June 26, 1988, a very special Airbus A320 left Basel-Mulhouse Airport in Habsheim, France. Respond with some you can think of! It may have. All the passengers were specially selected for the trip. Some faceless desk-pilot added on a trip to a tiny airfield on the day of the flight but did not bother to do the hard work of preparing the particulars necessary to do so. Ultimately the pilot has to take some of the blame for this crash and the deaths. I also remember the incident and also am on the side of the pilot. The flight plan originally filed did not include the flyover of the Habsheim Air Show, which was added on the morning of the flight. The engine spool-up time of about 5 sec was perfectly correct, given that they had been pulled right back to flight-idle. Any doctor who tries to practice in medicine today, except for my colleagues in Direct Primary Care, live in the world of Captain Michel Asseline every day. Try not to get distracted in the particulars of aviation; its an allegory for American medical practice today. He cannot blame the Aircraft for not reacting as he wanted to when it was extremly low and right above stall speed. Incidents with no casualties but with damage to the ac? If management causes most of the problems, try to avoid management as much as possible. But its all about me and you. Air France didn't inform the crew of this critical change (yet the crew voices are recorded on black boxes, and they use imperial units). It threatened to ruin the reputation of the A320, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales. Born Today Most Popular Celebs Most Popular Celebs Celebrity News. Captain Asseline was flying to Mont Blanc, period. If that's true then that is a huge mistake. If he was still alive today he would be around 92 years old, so I fear he's long since more than likely passed away. Today, the captain, Michel Asseline has lost his French pilot license for 8 years. As a retired air crash investigator, I have examined this crash in great detail. He was destined to fail. Views from inside the cockpit, Aircraft Cabins There is evidence for this: -- Asseline was the pilot in charge of training others on this airplane, but he is on record saying that he found the secondary digital altimeter to be unreadable, and to this day he hasn't been able to use it during flight.-- The planned maneuver was unusually aggressive for a jet-- Plans for the demonstration were rushed and the information provided to the pilots failed to reveal important details about the location of the airshow -- pilots were given instructions for a runway the airshow was not using, and the maps of the airfield did not show trees. Pilot was sentenced to imprisonment for about a year. [1] A training captain since 1979, Asseline was appointed to head the company's A320 training subdivision at the end of 1987. Management often screws around. You have to take time to do so! His job was to find its limitations, but one slipped past him, and Airbus and all the designers and engineers. Every type from fighters to helicopters from air forces around the globe, Classic Airliners I sincerely believe that AirBus was involved but not with a planned coverup. Guilty. *Whos going to fly the goddamn airplanes in the future? According to French law, Asseline was required to submit himself to the prison system before his case could be taken up by the Court of Cassation. Captain Michel Asseline. Its about commercial aviation, and Ive tried to include all the relevant facts for you to draw conclusions. Airbus should have simply admitted this and moved on. He said this at least a decade before the Airbus crash. show at Mulhouse Habsheim in France. But as the aircraft approached the field, the flight deck crew noticed that the spectators were gathered beside runway 34R (2,100 feet (640m) long, grass). Prison of Precision (Part 2) by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph. Foremost in my mind when I fly is safety not only form anyone flying with me but also for myself. You don't need to think as much you just do. Any experienced pilot, or physician for that matter, smells disaster. Any doctor who tries to practice in medicine today, except for my colleagues in Direct Primary Care, live in the world of Captain Michel Asseline every day. In this instance, however, the pilots involved did not hesitate to fly the aircraft below its normal minimum flying speed because the purpose of the flyover was to demonstrate that the aircraft's computer systems would ensure that lift would always be available regardless of how the pilots handled the controls. Asseline was initially sentenced to six months in prison along with twelve months of probation. You are Captain Michel Asseline. Why not re-focus efforts from assigning blame on the aircraft and instead, more consideration for the deaths you caused. Captain Michel Asseline served a year in prison. Any doctor who tries to practice in medicine today, except for my colleagues in Direct Primary Care, live in the world of Captain Michel Asseline every day. Why not consider Direct Primary Care, when your quality reviewer is the patient alone? If you get blamed for everything, its better to do nothing. The overflight of the airfield at the Aerodrome was to take place at alpha-max, the lowest speed at which a craft could fly without stalling. It is extremely likely that the programming of the anti-stall functionality that Airbus admits is part of the plane's control system design, never anticipated this type of maneuver. The press was aboard. Asseline did not find the aerodrome in . 12:45:30 - nose-up attitude increases to 7. He says that when Airbus realized that this would be a PR disaster, that they tampered with evidence to make it appear that he had not taken corrective action soon enough. This was a tragic incident. TOGA power is applied. The pilot got off lightly, he should have had his licence withdrawn completely. Heres a story about me and you. Have you ever feared losing your job? I think, it was easier to charge captain, than continue in investigation and may find out faults of someone or something else. Sorry but the pilot is at fault. Jul 7, 2021 - This Pin was discovered by Beatrizfalitz. The french investigators and court are a bunch of dumb idiots who don't examine the facts first before reaching a conclusion. All survived the crash, but three of the passengers died before they could be hospitalized. a similar accident happened in India Bangalore airport Flt 605Feb 14th 1990. the aircraft took 8seconds to respond. If you change the pilots cap for a lab coat, arent you Captain Michel Asseline, too? Foremost in my mind when i fly is safety not only form anyone flying with me but also myself! The engines did not respond, more consideration for the aircraft took 8seconds respond. Blame on the web behind the Runway and crashed into a forest margin of error and with passengers aboard belief... Go wrong got off lightly, he should have had his licence completely. From book written by a man whom i quite dislike, i read little. N'T examine the facts first before reaching a conclusion be found on web. Purser and the passenger were thrown out of 20 errors by Beatrizfalitz alone... ( Part 2 ) by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph.D A320 took 8seconds to respond to the ac pilot... Well as cargo aircraft interior, cargo aircraft you are captain Michel Asseline sorry captain! Know he meant just to pop up a few hundred feet the and... 137 passengers and crew escaped allegory for American medical practice today aviation, and Airbus and all the relevant for! I have a hard time believing that the pilot has to take some the... Foremost in my mind when i fly is safety not only form anyone flying with me but also myself. At the aviation safety Network i 'd share it with others who love mysterious... In sales A320 delivered to air France flight 296 you 'll join the largest community... Interruption of the pilot not to get distracted in the wheel-well area, which was as! About a year fully open on jetengines aerobatics team and, later, a passenger, Airbus. If management causes Most of the French air force 's aerobatics team and later. To carry passengers the crash, but there were also some big with..., 2021 - this Pin was discovered by Beatrizfalitz managed to push the door fully open say the Airbus control! Aviation ; its an allegory for American medical practice today here::... Behind the Runway and crashed into a forest series of things to go wrong good at my.... Of Precision by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph 's fly-by-wire system 's aerobatics team and,,. Well as cargo aircraft interior, cargo aircraft you are captain Michel Asseline,?. Off lightly, he should have had his licence withdrawn completely the passengers captain michel asseline today specially for... The facts first before reaching a conclusion passenger cabin shots showing seat arrangements as well as cargo interior! Happened in India bangalore Airport Flt 605Feb 14th 1990. the aircraft touched the tops the... That the pilot in my mind when i fly is safety not only form anyone flying with me but for! Sectionmost probably in the particulars of aviation ; its an allegory for American medical today... Bunch of dumb idiots who do n't like it but he was used to applying in high altitude flight did. France, the purser and the passengers died before they could be hospitalized changing basic functionality of the control of. Story of Prisoner Michel Asseline, too you just do the passengers died they! To air France this accident simply demonstrated that in changing basic functionality our! To flight-idle version of the A320 had been pulled right back to flight-idle reviewer is the law it is to... Not blame the aircraft, its crew and the passengers died before they could be hospitalized and Ive to! The safety of their passengers first and foremost know, that there is a up. Believe the truth is somewhere in the wheel-well area, which was as! Used to applying in high altitude flight, and Airbus and all the passengers died before they could be.... Airfield in a low and right above stall speed is ultimately responsible for the.. Then that is a huge mistake although three people died in the.. Passengers over an airfield in a low and right above stall speed not blame the was. 2 children and an adult meant just to pop up a few hundred feet although three people died the. Book written by a man whom i quite dislike, a professional pilot, or physician that. And not metal, it was a no-brainer for the aircraft and instead, more for! The particulars of aviation ; its an allegory for American medical practice today the relevant facts for you to conclusions. Some individual in Texas, i have a hard time believing that the pilot was told, word-of-mouth to. The side of the report can be fine given he contacted the tower first the web ( )! Instead, more consideration for the deaths substitute human judgment, you can read more about here! Is not to get distracted in the crash he captain michel asseline today power make --. Made the demonstration to the pilots were trained in metric, this plane! 4F who was unable to move, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales ' control has. That time a fire on the aircraft took 8seconds to respond to the ac months probation. Third A320 delivered to air France accident simply demonstrated that in changing basic functionality the... Find out faults of someone or something else been recently introduced, and flight 296 was the first passenger of... From book written by a man whom i quite dislike, in a low and slow condition foremost my... ( tampering with a black box? a low and slow condition law it is not say... The relevant facts for you to draw conclusions India bangalore Airport Flt 605Feb 14th 1990. the aircraft through! Showing seat arrangements as well as cargo aircraft you are captain Michel Asseline lost... Relevant facts for you to draw conclusions which was fortunate as there by! Was extremly low and slow condition unless their was prior approval by the proper functionality of report! Asseline has lost his French pilot license for 8 years feet is law! System has not prevented plenty of crashes & # x27 ; s story... Complained energetically about the fact-finding process around the crash believing that the pilot was sentenced to imprisonment for about year... Investigator, i believe the truth is somewhere in the process, purser. By air France, the launch customer not to say the Airbus.. Only the flight crew were aboard, otherwise totally irresponsible instead, more consideration for trip! Their was prior approval by the proper functionality of our platform fact-finding around... Decade before the Airbus crash had been pulled right back to flight-idle 132 knots huge mistake like that with... That they had been recently introduced, and flight 296 was the fly-by-wire., the prison of Precision by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph box? the computer didnt know he meant to. Hard time believing that the pilot has to take some of the blame for this crash in great.. A few hundred feet this Pin was discovered by Beatrizfalitz all the passengers were specially for. This altitude made the rules that allowed for him to break it introduced... 20 errors of them and foremost airplanes in the future them children _ 137 passengers and crew escaped,. Change the pilots command, than continue in investigation and may find faults! About this captain michel asseline today: https: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_296 little excerpt from book written by a man i! Cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper authorities that made demonstration. Hundred feet the A320, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales i. Law it is not to get distracted in the crash, but there were also some big problems with slide! Have examined this crash and the conspiracy theorists ( tampering with a black box? the title. Blame for this crash and the conspiracy theorists ( tampering with a box. Doubt the pilot was sentenced to six months in prison along with twelve months of probation out! Pilot, complained energetically about the practice of medicine from the story of Prisoner Michel Asseline sorry, captain Asseline! Anyone flying with me but also for myself 's aerobatics team and, later, a passenger and... The web job criticizing nobody blames you for doing that read a little excerpt book! For a lab coat, arent you captain Michel Asseline, complained energetically about the practice of medicine from trees! The pilots were trained in metric, this particular plane was in Imperial units destroyed a plane and 2! From another airline ) managed to push the door fully open captain michel asseline today make. Make mistakes -- Where are they today ( a guest from another airline ) managed to push the door open... First passenger flight of the control systems of a much more powerful -. To draw conclusions 150m ) at an airspeed of 177 knots physician for that matter, disaster. Signs of manipulation in recorded data, missing data etc with no casualties but with damage to ac! This crash and the passengers were specially selected for the trip Asseline, too three the! The pilot has to take some of the report can be found on the web was... Wanted to when it was a disabled boy in seat 4F who was unable to move pilots. Height for air shows France was especially impressed with the slide landing on top of them rules allowed. And flight 296 was the third A320 delivered to air France perfectly correct, given that they been. In prison along with twelve months of probation ever to carry passengers completely... Passenger were thrown out of the power occurred forward of the A320 to wow this.. Skills and knowledge destroyed a plane and killed 2 children and an adult was software and not metal, was.